My Tomato Pie

For more than 28 years, My Tomato Pie has been serving Amherst and Western New York with fresh, scratch-made Italian cuisine in a warm, family-friendly atmosphere. As a locally owned, fourth-generation family restaurant, we're proud to continue a tradition of great food and genuine hospitality that spans more than a century. Our menu features handcrafted pizzas, homemade pasta dishes, fresh salads, sandwiches, wings, seafood, and chef-inspired Italian specialties made with quality ingredients. Whether you're joining us for lunch, dinner, drinks with friends, or takeout, we're committed to making every meal memorable. Planning an event? My Tomato Pie offers full-service catering, convenient drop-off catering, and a private banquet room that accommodates up to 55 guests. Perfect for showers, birthdays, rehearsal dinners, business meetings, holiday parties, graduations, and celebrations of all kinds. From family dinners to large catered events, our team is dedicated to delivering exceptional food, outstanding service, and the hometown hospitality that has made My Tomato Pie a Western New York favorite. Locally Owned. Locally Loved. Proudly Serving Western New York Since 1998.